Armed Robber

A guy runs out in front of the Impala and Dean has to quickly lock the brakes to avoid hitting him. As they get his story, on why he was running away in the first place, we soon learn that he will be the next victim, despite Dean and Sam's attempts to get him out of his sentence. He just got out of prison for an armed robbery in 1981, but even though he served his time, now he's going to die for his past actions. This is really a harsh judgement being passed down.

Red Dirt

Sam has noticed that all the crime scenes had red dirt and now we find out that the dirt came from an apple farm near the area. Of course the boys have to go check it out because they're Winchesters and that's what they do.

Dog-Fighting

And now we're getting the newspaper report on the second victim. He was arrested for dog-fighting, thus the reason he was killed by the dog. But, again, he had turned his life around. If there's no room for forgiveness, is their judgement really fair?

Invisible Dogs

And it looks like our next victim is now appearing. A guy is running down the street, trying to escape a dog who is chasing him. Dogs chasing guys is never good on this show, especially when one guy is the only one that sees them. So, these deaths are caused by hallucinations?

Back to Basics

The guys get to do an old-fashioned graveyard search while researching a name. I guess we really are going back to basics this season. But, alas, it's not a dig, but a connection to the victim. Hit and run when the guy was drunk. So, I guess their victim wasn't as squeaky clean as first thought.

Brotherly Bonding

Who gets to take on what aspect of the case? Let's solve this with brotherly bickering. I love when Sam and Dean get to do this. They haven't been able to do that lately, what with all the pain and torture they've been through.

The First Victim

The victim was in AA, 10 years sober. So, it seems like he was a nice guy. Weird that he'd be destined to die for his wrong-doings. Unless it's a trial of any crimes they've ever done, whether they've made up for them in human standards or not.